Skip to content

How AI-Driven Male Fantasies Contributed to Anti-Migrant Riots and the "Far-Right Multitude," ft/ Beatriz Lopes Buarque

Episode 71 · May 13th, 2026 · 1 hr 4 mins

About this Episode

Right-wing authoritarian and extremist movements are on the march worldwide. This podcast will host some of the globe's leading experts on the radical right to help us understand the development of these extremists. Each episode, hosts and guests bring their specialist insights to break down the critical people, places, organizations, actions, and ideas of the radical right. Produced by the Centre for Analysis of the Radical Right

Transcript

Hello, and welcome

to Right Rising, the official podcast

of the Far Right Analysis Network. I'm

your host, Alexander Reed Ross, and

today I am thrilled to be here with

Beatriz López-Buarque. Dr. Buarque is a

political scientist and a fellow at the

Interdisciplinary Social Science School at London

School of Economics. So, welcome to the pod, Dr. Buarque. thank you so much for

having me yeah i was looking forward for

this moment yeah same here it's been

it's been a long time that we've been trying

to uh work out the dates and everything

and it's great that we can finally make

it happen yeah so um you've been you were

Read Full Transcript Hide Full Transcript

you were part of the original car group

and you know we all kind of a lot of us

floated over into this fran network and uh

you know a lot has happened since then i

think that was maybe like five or six years

ago so um uh it's cool that i think you finished

your dissertation and you're doing a

lot of teaching and public speaking and

all of that kind of stuff so it's it's

been it's been part of part of the rewarding

thing of remaining in this network has

been to see you know colleagues continue to

succeed and it's great to touch base with

you yeah many things change but it's good

that we remain connected I agree so I first

wanted to compliment you on your exciting

use of psychoanalytical theory to develop

some essential themes in the field of right

-wing studies because that's something that

we don't see that much of and it's

really fun to explore. It's really an

interesting field and it's kind of neglected in

my opinion. So your recent article Algorithms

at Your Service is about the 2024 anti

-migrant riots in England. Can you discuss for

some context, the riots that happened and

the methodology that you use to understand

social media's role. Yeah, sure. So

these riots, they happened in the

summer of 2024. And to many

researchers, it was considered the

worst far right riot since the

Second World War. And And the thing

is that everything started with a horrifying stabbing of three

girls in Southport. And immediately

after this attack, we had some fake news

about the identity of the perpetrator

of the attack. And these fake news

started, like, spread very rapidly across

different digital platforms. People

started using telegram and also acts to

mobilize violent action, to come after

muslins, to come after hotels, allegedly

housing asylum seekers. And all of a

sudden, many British towns and

cities, they were with these outbursts

of violence. and when we had these

riots what really captured my attention

is that much of the coverage was focused

on the relationship between fake news and

violence as if fake news were like the main

motivator of the violence but deep inside

I was thinking that it was not really just

fake news there was like these xenophobic

islamophobic sentiments they were already

around for I would say like decades and

so what I decided and other a few researchers

were also looking at the role played by

conspiracy theories disinformation campaigns

because they noticed some accounts

weaponizing information. So I decided to delve

into this, to delve into the role played by

visual representations of racist conspiracy

theories, such as the Great Replacement and

the White Genocide. And I explored two

main hypotheses here. First, that digital

platforms such as X amplified these visual

representations of racist conspiracy

theories at a different speed in comparison

to other content and at a different

scale. And the other hypothesis was that these

visual representations, they were really

appealing to violence because the Great

Replacement and the white genocide are two

conspiracy theories that are often used

as a justification for white supremacist

terrorist attacks. So it is already

well documented the relationship between

these conspiracy theories and violence and the

methodology that i used was basically

the methodology that i designed for my uh

doctoral studies which i call multimodal

critical effect discourse analysis that

integrates quantitative analysis into discourse

analysis so at first We ran a regression

between the total number of views and

the total number of likes, comments, and

shares of this post featuring visual

representations of racist conspiracy theories

on two X accounts, Europe Invasion and

Britain First. First, the European invasion

was already well -known at that moment

because it was already engaged in

disinformation campaigns. And the second part

of the methodology was to really engage with

psychoanalysis and explore some of the

fantasies conveyed through these images.

and we managed to confirm the two

hypotheses it was very interesting actually

to see that x amplified that visual representation

post featuring visual representations

of racist conspiracy theories they

were amplified about 30 percent more than

the other content and those post

featuring images created with generative AI tools,

their amplification was even more

disproportionate. They were reaching like

millions of views. And by focusing

on these specific images created

with generative AI, it was very

interesting, Alex, to see the role of

algorithmic bias, which is often

overlooked in our field. And in my view, So

this is actually one of the most nocive

sides of artificial intelligence, because

we're talking here about stereotypical

representations of Muslims and black people

that have been so present in Western

culture that they remain unnoticed when it

comes to content moderation. And people

don't even get shocked anymore because they

became normalized. And that's why they

are so harmful. so yeah in a nutshell

these were like the main findings

and the methodology that i used for this

uh research project yeah that's so weird

that so many people were so excited to

be sharing these ai images um as

though they were real but as though they

could enable this fantasy you know i

don't know but uh you understand the riots

as enabling and fulfilling this kind

of social fantasy of the englishman right

this kind of god -ordained crusader

against the victimization of pure english

women so this sort of you know the knight

in shining armor chivalrous sort of old

fantasy that you like you said is like as

old as england so how is this

fantasy conveyed on social media and

how is it understood or recognized

by those who adopt it what are the

kind of tropes you know that you see in

the ai video or uh images and the kind

of myth being spun. Yeah, the tropes are

so like common that I think that's precisely

the most nocive part of this content,

because precisely because they have been

so normalized, people don't even pay

attention. So it is as if their invisibility

made this content particularly harmful.

So the tropes here that I saw was like

associations between black individuals, particularly

black men with criminality, with

disorder, muslins portrayed as sexual

predators. So surrounding, posing a threat to

white British women. And another fantasy

that was very prominent is this fantasy of the

white hero. the white heroic warrior, as if

white men were, white European men, were

entitled to take violent action, to restore

order, to save their homeland, to save the

so-called, the perceived sacred body of white

European women. So these fantasies, they were

very, very prominent, and we could see this

constructed in different ways through videos

showing bleeding white men as if they

were giving their blood to save Britain from

the so-called invaders, invasors. um and then

genitive ai created images they showed very

um how can i say very strong white men there

always as if they were like a role model hero

and uh several boats behind this white hero

who was there standing to save england and

another one that comes to mind was these

genitive AI-created images that resembles

one of these promotional material produced for

movies like Avengers. So opposing a white man, Christian, to a black Muslim and

surrounded by other Muslims and with the

parliament in flames. so it is as if there

was only one single hero there standing

against all the others pure evil guys so it

was very like and and it's very interesting i

think it's fascinating something here alex

that when we talk about these images

people people know that these images are not

real they they they have the aesthetics of memes

so why exactly are they engaging with

this And I think that the why really has to

do with this fantasy of the white hero,

this fantasy of saving their homeland, because

these images, they serve as instruments

to fantasize violence. so even these people

if these people cannot go to the street

and like physically attack muslims by

sharing these images it is as if they were

saying oh we support these we are the heroes

these people should not be here so yeah

again it goes back to the sort of fantasy

world of the online space i think to

some degree i mean a lot of people who share

these kinds of memes probably would go

out into the streets if they had the chance

or what have you. But particularly, and when you think about it, the riot is the ultimate non-individualized

context, at least as it's framed

sort of sociologically over the last couple

hundred years, I guess. The riot is

considered like a mass phenomenon, a collective

action, or like Kinetti, like the the

herd you know the violent herd um and often

with the connotations like race riots and

anti-semitic pogroms and that kind of thing

so to stage it as like the one individual

standing against the horde is to invert the

concept or the context and um and and arrive

at a position of dignity for what is

otherwise morally considered unjustifiable

within civil society. To have a riot in

England, you know, in a monarchy, a

parliamentary monarchy, right? It's not

considered a great thing, you know, for a

patriot to actually do. so they're inverting

it in order to make it blend in with the

myth and the lore uh that sort of england

proceeds from almost um it's a pale and

genetic thing right um so i want to like this

also makes me think a lot about the flag of

saint george and how it's used especially you

said something really interesting that it's

invisibility almost sort of grants it

power and and um uh pervasion it makes it

spread uh uh much easier i don't remember exactly

what you said i wish i had written it down

but um the flag of saint george is a really

good example of this right because it's sort

of considered england before the union

right it's like more english than the union

jack or whatever and um it is sort of has a

cross what's that and it has a cross and it

as a cross yeah so can you talk a little bit

about how the i don't know i don't know if

you've written about this or thought about

i'm sure you've thought about it a lot but for

a while i think the flag of saint george

was being used as a white supremacist white

nationalist signifier is that a similar

case of like this is such a common thing

you know that it can spread so easily

I think that the weaponization of the

flag can be attributed in largely part to

this intersection of white supremacy

and Christianity. And this mindset,

this appeal to the crusade. This is very

interesting because these conspiracy theories,

both the Great Replacement and the

white genocide, they appeal to this crusading

mentality. So it is as if on a fantasy

level, they were activating these individuals

as heroes who should go on a crusade to

save their people. So it's a very, very

strong appeal, almost as if they were

literally chosen by God. And this happens on

an unconscious level. Some people, they really project heroes

consciously. And these, I would

say that they are like the white supremacists,

the ones that to like verbally express

this. But we have many individuals who

engage on a similar level, but without like

making it explicit, because it is really

in the unconscious. They feel it is a

matter of feeling. And I think that when

I was getting ready for this interview,

I saw some of your comments, and I don't

remember the sentence that you used, but

I fully agree that races, we still have

racism, we still have xenophobia, we still

have Islamophobia, anti-Semitism, all these discriminatory

ideologies, because they offer some

enjoyment. people enjoy engaging with these

ideologies because on an unconscious level they

it is as if they were making them feel special

so it is as if like oh my gosh we are so

superior so better than the others that they

are trying to destroy us they are trying

they're coming here invading our country and

we really need to get together because

they're coming after us because we are the best

so it is really it really has an effective

component there that unfortunately is still

very overlooked in our in our field right

that's why i was really excited to read your

work um you write about um identities right so

you're talking about this sort of christian

western crusader particularly the english

nationalist right um and uh kind of going

back to like georgic nationalism of like

slaying the dragon and you know like ancient sort

of myths so you know your work develops a

theory where the desire to complete or fulfill

identities amounts to something called

surplus jouissance uh which i think means joy in

french um yeah yeah can you elaborate a

little bit on jouissance and why a kind of ego

fantasy would activate it yeah i'll try to

make sense of these inaccessible terms

so yes to sense means enjoyment and in lacanian

psychoanalysis we have this concept of surplus

to a sense which basically means like

fullness so it is as if unconsciously we had

some fullness as object of desire but we are

constantly looking for this fullness and this

fantasy that at some point we will reach

this fullness keep us engaged with the pursuit

because we enjoy these like we enjoy this

repeated act of missing our object of desire

i know when i say this is very abstract but

i'll give an example and it will make sense

for instance when we are engaging with

instagram we consciously know that it's impossible

to watch everything that is there on

instagram we know and we may also consciously

consciously know that we are there like

wasting time we could do other things but we're

still there why because we enjoy we enjoy

these unconscious like fantasy of reaching some

fullness of reaching like reading assessing

everything that we can a similar dynamics

operates for instance with our engagement with knowledge, for instance. Why do we keep reading? Why do we keep studying? Because deep inside

we have this fantasy that at some point

we will become the master, we will become

super knowledgeable. It's impossible to

achieve this fullness. But the desire to

get closer keeps us in the pursuit

of this fullness. Now, how is this

linked to racists? Because fear is a

racist and identity. It is linked through a concept that

Dijek developed. We have other frameworks,

but I like this concept developed by

Dijek that is called Chat of Enjoyment.

so the jack explains racism and xenophobia

through this framework saying that why do

some individuals they they express strong

xenophobic and racist sentiment and racist

sentiments they express this because they

unconsciously perceive black individuals

and migrants as enjoying something

that they should not be enjoying that was not

supposed to be theirs so then they engage

with racism and xenophobia because

it is as if it was like a mechanism

of defense to try to reclaim this

enjoyment that should not be on the

hands of the others and um and i think that

if we look at racism and xenophobia and

islamophobia through this perspective i

think many things start to make sense because

it is really on in the unconscious It's

really about these fantasies that somebody

is reaching some fullness that should

not be theirs. And then there is this pursuit

for this fullness. And conspiracy theories

come in the middle because they serve

as a refuge. because conspiracy theories

they project these fantasies showing white

european particularly men as entitled to the

fullness did i make sense i think so yeah

so i think i i um i i shared this article

with you by brian hughes about conspiracy

theories where he argues that conspiracy

theories try to draw people away from the

sort of symbolic realm identified with the

father and like structure and order and pull

them back to this kind of pre-edible sense of

unity with the mother where you have this

feeling of unitary sovereignty and power

and you know there's nothing else to be kind

of jealous of you're going into this state

of satisfaction and wholeness right and

hold yes exactly so it seems like you guys

are kind of saying something very similar

it's very interesting uh how this sort of adds up

in the psychoanalytical way um but uh so

just to sort of try to see if I have it

kind of right. So it seems like the memes

that you looked at that show white women being

scandalized by brown and black men are not

about rescuing the women from that paradigm,

but kind of replacing the brown and black

bodies with white ones. In other words,

the reactionary male fantasy, the white male

fantasy here, is that the non-whites have

unmitigated access to women's bodies while

the white men don't so in essence the far

right are jealous of the non-white man's

perceived boundless jouissance while their

own enjoyment is always frustratingly partial

is that right like they they wanna they

want the access to women that they think the

other has yeah it's it's at the core of uh

of these um gender and racial issues surrounding

um these ideologies it is really at the

core they really um they project themselves

as the as the ones who should have like

full access to the bodies of white european

women but something but we must make a

distinction here because when we talk about it's

very interesting this we need to distinguish

the value attributed to the bodies of white

European women and the bodies of non-white,

non-European women because it's very

interesting that white European men, they project

themselves as entitled to the body of women

regardless of race and ethnicity but But

the bodies of white European women is perceived

as sacred, because it is their wombs that

will give birth to the next generation of

leaders, whereas the bodies of non-white, non

-European women is perceived as disposable,

just for entertainment. right right okay yeah

i wonder how that tracks with because

there's this projection of sacredness on the

white woman but and how does that track with

the kind of ultra misogynistic patriarchy

right so it seems to me like the white

woman is only sacred in relation to the other

and once you take the other and replace

with the fully satisfied white male the

sacredness of the white woman diminishes as

she becomes his object in a sense i don't

know if i understood well i don't know what

i'm saying at all so i'm just saying i'm

saying like it's sacred i think alex sorry

I think that's the misogynist framework is

focused on feminists. So when white

European women are not conforming to this

ideal of femininity, then they become

problematic and then, yes, they

channel hate. Because if they are conforming

to the ideal of femininity, then

they are sacred. yeah which is is like

an impossible ideal again so we're talking

about identity and it fulfills yes we're

talking about fullness again yeah yeah yeah

exactly neither so neither are really

fulfillable like this kind of like chivalrous

heroic white man nor the sacred you know white

woman they're both ideals that contribute

and drive this anger and violence exactly

exactly i think i get it now yeah and they

keep trapped into this cycle because they

don't have awareness about this we don't

talk about this and we also don't have like

a coordinated effort to challenge these uh

stereotypical representations of men and women

of migrants muslims uh on a societal level

yeah so this question is complicated because

i'm not defining any of these terms

and they're kind of being left open which

is kind of my fault but uh They're controversial

terms. So you talk about, you write

about paranoia and narcissism playing important

roles in the process of jouissance that

motivates xenophobia. In a sense, you're

kind of saying that for racists and

ultra-nationalists, xenophobia feels

good, right? Yes. I think that

we touched upon this slightly when we said that

racism and xenophobia, Islamophobia, they

are based on this enjoyment. People are

racist and xenophobic, Islamophobic because they

enjoy projecting their resentment, their

grievances towards the other who is perceived

to be enjoying something that was not supposed

to be theirs when it comes to these

terms paranoia and narcissism i would be

careful to associate these terms with my work

first because paranoia pretty much similar

to hofstether i'm not using the term paranoia

in clinical terms in clinical in the

clinical sense and Lacan himself said that all

human beings we have some paranoic dimension it

is part of our nature because this paranoic

dimension is part of our construction of

subjectivity what we have are degrees of

this paranoic dimension and if they get

extreme yes we can have psychosis which is a

clinical condition but i'm not talking about this

pathological state and narcissism is some

is a concept that i really didn't engage with

in my work i mentioned this because the

literature on conspiracy theories part of the

literature acknowledges the relationship

between conspiracy theories and conspiracy

mindset and narcissism but it's not really

really part of my work yeah got it i i

think narcissism kind of fascinating one

because you have the freudian definition

which i think was the over evaluation

of uh sexual uh ability i think that's

how he defined it in in um one of those

essays that he wrote um but uh it also i

think kind of can be interpreted in keeping

with this whole kind of structure of

identity and subjectivity yeah yeah you know

so this is kind of a fruitful domain

i think to to include i think you it's

one it's like in one sentence in one of

your papers so this is like this is very

like i'm like back in grad school right

now i'm like a grad student like um can

i ask you a 20 minute long question please

dr oh oh my gosh yes jesus christ all right all right so you

have another recent article and i think

your dissertation kind of does this as well

It's like putting post-Marxists and

autonomous Marxists into conversation together,

right? So there's a lot to unpack here.

I really fundamentally agree with your

main theses here. So let's just cover

the basics. Can you explain to me the difference

between these two? So I make sure

that I have it. The post-Marxists and

the autonomous Marxists. and what they say

about anti-capitalist movements okay i'll

try to make sense of this because this was

the most complex like and difficult part of

my thesis because i decided to bring

together uh here we are focused on marxist but

in my thesis i bring together marxist lacan

and foucault like people will never be together

but i did it so uh when it comes to

Autonomist Marxists and Post-Marxists, Autonomist

Marxists, their work remains loyal to

this classical Marxist dichotomy between

the capital and the proletariat, but they

perceived the proletariat as autonomous, as

creative, as productive, not as solely react

to capital. That was the main difference

between Autonomist Marxists and the

Classical Marxists. Post-Marxists,

they were slightly different in the sense

that they represent a departure from

this fundamental antagonism between

the capital and the proletariat to

understand the multiple struggles that coexist

within capitalism. And I know that when

I say post-Marxist, we tend to perceive

these as a homogeneous theoretical strand,

but it's really not homogeneous. We have some

clashes among them, and I think that some of

the clashes, they have to do with their

perception of democracy, over the relationship

between capitalism and democracy. Because

those aligned with the work of Laclau and

Shalfa Mufu, they tend to perceive that

capitalism, the struggles that we have within

capitalism will eventually result in a radical

type of democracy. and those more

aligned with the jack and i include

myself here don't really agree with

this because we think and i would i

cannot say for the others but for

instance i think that if we assume that

these multiple antagonisms will

result in radical democracy we

are really like working with the

assumption that capitalism is the only viable

economic system there. We are not open to

other possibilities. And also we are

overlooking the differences among these

antagonist groups. And we are also

overlooking how class issues underpin all

these antagonist groups. So that's why I

don't really like. unless there are

fundamental changes in society and everything

i don't really agree with this thesis of

the radical democracy proposed by post

-marxists but yes these are the main differences

between post-marxist and autonomous marxist

is that clear i think so i i think

like so you have the autonomous marxists who

say that the kind of revolutionary subject

is like very diverse uh and multiple and

so we're no longer kind of focused on the

proletariat or rather expanding concept of

the proletariat to include this kind of

multitude for the post these are the post

-marxists those are the post-marxist okay

autonomous marxists so post-marxists are like

the social movements yes yes yes okay

autonomous marxists are much more still

attached to the critique of capitalism? Yes,

they are much more attached to these

antagonism between capital and the proletariat. Yes. But they perceive the

proletariat not as merely reacting to

capital. They see the proletariat as creative,

as productive. And that's why the main

thesis of autonomous Marxists that precisely

because the proletariat is productive they

will eventually start producing a common

that will eventually lead to the destruction

of capitalism and the rise of what they

call global democracy. So it's very

interesting that both post-Marxists and

autonomous Marxists they see some

positive, amazing thing at the end of the

tunnel. in different ways but they

see i see but the autonomists hang on

to the fundamental antagonism um yeah

yeah and uh the post -marxists see it as a

more kind of constructive movement sort of yeah

yeah post-marxists they don't they don't

revolve around class struggle so they understand

the struggles revolving around race gender

and we have these atomized uh power

struggles coexisting within capitalism got it okay

so you put them in conversation together

what what's the what's the sort of purpose

and and the outcome of of um having them kind

of um um I don't know connected dialoguing

arguing what's the what it what is the what's

the yeah so so I staged a dialogue between

then because I think that both theories

related to democracy proposed by autonomous

Marxist and post-Marxist they have valid points

I just think that they overlooked the

intrinsic relationship between racism and

capitalism. And this is exactly what I tried

to recover through my understanding of the alt

-right as a multitude. So basically what happens

is that autonomous Marxists, their theory

of the multitude says that contemporary

capitalism is based on effective labor so

it is our effects that have been quantified

monetized and people are constantly

encouraged to engage in collaboration to

communicate to produce commonalities and according

to autonomous marxists this thing that

we share in common communication stories

facts i don't know things that we share in common

online for instance would lead to the

emergence of a social body, a creature that

would eventually lead to the downfall

of capitalism, that would project

itself against capitalism. That

is their theory. But then, in my view,

what they forgot is that if we live

in a capitalist system, that people

are constantly encouraged to just

react and share things in common and

everything, but our capitalist system

is sustained by a racist, an anti

-supremacist ideological dimension in an

unconscious level, it means that many

people will start reacting and actually

sharing content that feeds these

unconscious fantasies. And this explains,

for instance, the amplification of conspiracy

theories, because conspiracy theories,

they serve as this refuge. and that is the

theoretical framework that I use, the

dread and refuge that when we had the so

-called refugee crisis we had all these

anxieties about mass immigration so these

migrants are coming here they are changing our

culture they are taking our women they really

pose a threat to our society so there was

these anxieties people were really like There

was a discomfort, but nobody was really

talking about the problems of the neoliberal

capitalist system. No, they were

trying to make sense, but

through narratives that would be

easy to consume. And these narratives

are conspiracy theories, because

conspiracy theories, they offer a sense of

orientation, of explanation, and they activate

these fantasies. these racist fantasies.

So what happens is, instead of

collaboratively engaging in the production of

common narratives that would eventually

come together and create the social being

against capitalism, no, they came

together around these conspiracy theories. And

then we had the emergence of this creature of

the internet called alt-right, and the

alt-right has managed to survive and keep

amplifying discourses, and now they are

amplified, they are mainstreaming,

legitimized, and all that. So I think that

that is the reason why I felt the

need of stage in this dialogue,

because autonomous Marxists, they were

very optimistic. They totally

neglected the racist underpinnings of the

capitalist system. And the post-Marxists,

I actually engaged with the Dijekian

framework, because Dijekian saw this ideological

dimension in the unconscious but jack also didn't

focus on race so that's why i had to

bring these two together i see okay i think i

understand so you have the autonomists and

the post-marxists and both of them see like

during the 90s 80s and 90s uh this kind of

horizon of liberation and democracy uh that's

going to happen in the future like if you look

at empire by negrian heart there's a sense

that neoliberalism is accelerating the

conditions through which the proletariat will

eventually sort of yeah find liberation uh

globally by the class conditions of accumulation

of capital and so on. So you have the,

they're the antagonism between the bourgeoisie

and the proletariat or what have you. And on

the other hand, and you're saying that we

didn't see that happen because even though that

acceleration process of accumulation took

place, the proletariat, the base did not come

into did not realize the consciousness of

of its revolutionary subjectivity so that

didn't work and um or it hasn't yet maybe knock

on wood i guess i don't know um and then

the post-marxists were saying like new social

movements are forming and they are going to

propel a more democratic system that is

disconnected from um the class antagonism and

by maybe by delinking from class antagonism

and developing the social movements

they'll be able to um basically overcome

the the the crisis of bourgeoisie and proletariat

and the existence of of class right and

that didn't happen either and part of

reason for that is that they don't recognize

that the class and the other forms of oppression

are linked like capitalism and the other

forms of oppression are linked um and so

you can't just pick capitalism out of

it and now you have zizek who was making

that claim but zizek didn't recognize the

importance of race yeah and you i mean you got

it amazing also i know it's incredible that

i actually was able to put that together

i was able to repeat exactly what you said

worse than you said it but um you know

would you also include like gender and sexual

discrimination uh when you talk about race

or for you is it race and class race and

capital no i also included gender and sexuality

i didn't touch upon a lot but gender

for sure yes yeah yeah okay so i get it and

and this is where so and this is

where i think your analysis is so on point

is that you're saying like we're in like the

upside down of what was being predicted

by the autonomists and the post-Marxists

because we have a situation where we do have a

multitude but it's completely not class

conscious and instead is sort of fragmenting

partly through disinformation and whatever

but it's fragmenting I'm just saying that

myself you didn't say that I'm saying that um

fragmenting into like nationalist movements

that are destroying democracy yeah it is

actually it is actually fragmenting towards

the consolidation of white supremacy and

patriarchy they're going on the opposite

direction so it's not accumulating towards

an internationalist sort of democracy

it's disintegrating yeah yeah yeah yeah

so they were right in a sense of their

analysis of the conditions but they

were overly optimistic that That people

would really abandon the discriminatory and

oppressive frameworks that bring them

jouissance, I guess. Yeah, and I think

that acknowledging the role of the unconscious

is very important, Alex, because let's

stop and think about our capitalist system

for a moment. I really like the concept

of effective capitalism, because right

now, what has been quantified and

monetized are our bodily reactions to the contents

that we see online. And these reactions,

they are based on both conscious and unconscious

elements. So, for instance, if we open

our Instagram feed and we start watching a

video, very often, I would say most of the time,

we don't think why we are watching that

specific video. We're just watching and

enjoying. It's unconscious. But the system is

already monetizing. It doesn't care about

your intention, if you're thinking or

not. just the act of directing our attention

of watching it is already turning that into

profits and that's why i think our capitalist

system nowadays is very nocive because

it is quantifying and monetizing something

that we have no control we may have control

if we raise awareness about these and start

consciously engaging with the platforms but

then it takes a lot of emotional effort

emotional labor is not it's not that easy and

i think that is where it gets very nosive

and that is where this intersection between

capitalism racist fantasies xenophobic

fantasies sexist fantasies they really come into

play because we are talking here about

billions of people reacting to content just

because they are seeking your sense enjoyment

and this enjoyment has become profitable

right yeah so it's almost like yeah yeah

yeah yeah it's like um in the in the 1930s you

couldn't wheat paste a poster on the side

of a building and then get paid five seconds

every time somebody looked at it right so you

know the the framework of of monetization

in experience itself has um has incentivized

um yeah has incentivized i don't know has

incentive unconscious enjoyments to a degree

but there's something more there right there's

like a unconscious enjoyment of things

that are negative that's what i think is

really kind of intense because there are

studies that show that um right-wing like

conservative minded people tend to be more uh

attracted to like negative images so like the

show like um images to people like

flowers and you know a sunny day and then like

a mosquito and then or like something

that's dead or something like that and

actually conservatives will be more interested

in like looking at and dwelling on

the negative images so if it's

incentivized to have negative images

then it will also be activating

a certain aspect of jouissance

right like a certain part of it that can

can be uh tend can tend towards right-wing um

I guess imaginaries and fantasies and that

sort of thing that's interesting I didn't

know that thanks for sharing I'll send you

uh the paper um maybe I can find it anyway

um so you also write with Polina Zavarszynskaya

the wonderful Polina uh who I've

interviewed for I think I've interviewed

Polina for this podcast anyway she's great for

Polydemos which is um run out of uh the

catholic university in milan um by a good

friend of the pod uh valerio alfonso bruno

so that's a wonderful convergence um about

the politics of truth on the far right

so uh last question and thanks for being

so patient with me no thank you for the

interview how so how is truth constructed

on the right and what can be done when

passionately held truths rely on almost rely

almost entirely on fabricated information

yeah i think that i would say that is

in my view the most fascinating part of my

work because that is the moments that I bring

together Dijek, Lacan and Foucault and the

thing is that we have we have this multitude of

people engaging with conspiracy theories to

satisfy their desires and the interesting

thing is that part of the commonality produced

by this multitude is actually these

discourses performed as truth. Conspiracy theories

performed as truth. So I'm really

recovering here this aspect of

autonomous Marxism that the multitude

is productive. But in this case,

the multitude is productive not

only because it is producing

common narratives, but because it is

producing common truths that have

become so widely circulated that

they have started influence

policymaking influence violent action that

they are becoming normalized so from

this perspective if we look at the

so-called truths produced by this

multitude of actors aligned with the

far-right mindset we can see we can

understand very clearly why a conspiracy theory

that use it to be restricted to white

nationalist circles and to white supremacist

manifestos is now a part of political campaigns.

It's now even informing policy agendas,

for instance, when in Brazil, cultural

Marxism was one of the pillars of the government

of Jair Bolsonaro. The great

replacement is now explicitly echoed

in British politics. It's normalized. and this is i think

that is very important for us to talk about

these because these are not harmless

conspiracy theories we already know that they

are dangerous conspiracy theories and when

they acquire this status of truth in my

view they become even more dangerous because

psychologically speaking when we understand

something as truth it tends to motivate

us to take action. I always give

an example. If we were here in

a class, in a room, there was

a fire alarm. How long would

it take for us to leave the building? If we are just there

and there is a fire alarm, we would

discuss and think, oh, is this really, is

this real, is this not? It would take

a few minutes for us to leave the room,

leave the building. But if there was a

fire alarm and the firefighter entered

the room and said, we need to leave, nobody

would think we would leave immediately.

Why? Because the firefighter is the

authority when it comes to fire. When it

comes to truth and scientific truth, the

authority are academics. At least until

now, we remain the authority when it comes

to scientific truth. And the problem is,

one of the problem is that this authority

has been historically associated with the

figure of a white european man and now we have

many white european men producing racist conspiracy

theories homophobic conspiracy theories

as truth engaging with the same manner of

speaking referencing dubious scholarship

publishing books that can be easily accessible

on amazon for instance or even recommended by

google scholar so we have all this system

these apparatus of our discriminatory so

-called truths widely available on the internet

and we even have like foundations of also

promoting this and in my view this is very

serious and that's why i wrote this paper with

polina she looked at content produced by i

think german a german media outlet and i focus

on content produced by alternative patriotic

because interesting alex here in the uk we

have these grassroots organizations

developing curriculums alternative curriculums

with mentions to white genocide cultural marxism

and even like giving advice for for parents

to not enroll their the children in the

schools because the content that the children will

get to their schools is indoctrination

is not good for the family values so we

already have this year and yeah i think this

is this is the trend that is very worrisome

and we just had a workshop on these and

we'll have another one now in september in

italy to also explore this topic within

the European context. That's really interesting.

Yeah, some part of me thinks like it's

because there's been a slackening of a

commitment, right, by like institutional authorities

toward the center because of problems

with the kind of normal economic and political

order that they can't really address given

the same sort of positionality and ideology

that they have been using, right? So in

like the post-war era or, you know, the 1950s,

1960s, you had a lot of like liberals who

were also sort of like socially conscious

and would be much more active in trying to

weed out and exclude or marginalize these

types of behaviors and attitudes underlying

conspiracy theories and so forth. but um there

the the problem of i mean i don't want to

be like uh it's all neoliberalism type of

guy you know like uh neoliberalism is responsible

for everything and so on but the problem

of of the accumulation of capital that you

were bringing up before created a crisis of

legitimacy yeah and so the center hasn't

really been able to hold on to its sort of

authority and you have like you're saying a lot

of other people vying for legitimacy who have

the same manner the same look sometimes

right they're still they're like white men

in suits they're supposed to be the ones who

know things and are in charge or whatever yeah

so uh and then they're they're just sort of

instead of instead of addressing the the

real problems they're creating um they're

fabricating a way of gaining power for themselves

right like accruing more and more power

Like, they're exploiting and capitalizing on

the accumulation of capital and throwing

democratic process into authoritarianism. Yeah.

And something that I notice a lot in

academia is another thing is that the intellectual

performance of these individuals projecting

themselves as authoritative actors

when it comes to truth on the internet is slightly

different from the performance that we

have of academics within academia in the sense

that they are really trying to reach out

people on the internet. And they are very

good in adopting this conversational tone

with the public, in the sense that these

so-called academics, but some of them are

really academics, so these individuals

performing conspiracy

theories as truth, they perform

intellectual authority, but they try to

engage in a dialogue with the public. So

they don't remain in what Nietzsche's

called that ivory tower. No,

they're coming down. And this has been one

of my main criticisms in academia, because

many of us have remained there in the ivory

tower. So if we remain there in the ivory

tower, we will never address this problem,

because the public doesn't feel that they

can connect with us. and in my view

this problem will even get even

worse with advances in artificial

intelligence because now what

is the difference between like if we

don't find our authentic voice if we don't

try to come down and really talk

to the public and everything we will

really fall behind and I don't know

what's going to happen but

it won't be good yay that's sad all right

um no but i think i i mean you're uh that's

that's the the correct analysis right the the

artificial intelligence is going to be used

to manufacture uh the same types of

truths right that aren't actually factual and

only speak to narratives that uh empower certain

people over others and by bringing them

this kind of direct shot of of joy enjoyment

of things that are actually quite negative

you know and so um you know as you've shown

artificial intelligence is already being used

to sort of fulfill people's fantasy ego

you know ego ideal or whatever um And it

will continue and it will even take the place

of the one in authority, you know. So as the

central authority of a kind of democratic

administration continues to erode, that

position of authority is going to be replaced

by computers that are seen as sort of

geniuses, but underneath are being fed on you

know uh bias the same matrix of of of weirdly

connected and disjointed facts that produce uh

conspiracy theories yes great synthesis

alex thanks for that thank you so much um

uh dr buarque thank you so much for joining

the podcast really appreciated reading

your work uh do you have any articles that are

are forthcoming anything any books or fun

stuff coming up no not yet Alex I'm I need to

take a break now taking a break all right

good yeah that's good yeah because when I come

back I will I need to write my book and I

need to start the other research project I

have many things to do so right now I'm taking

a break but thank you so much for having

me i really enjoyed this conversation it

was the first time that i had this deep conversation

on my work since my viva examination

so it was really good people are always

like yeah okay no no i appreciate it too that

i i do this to keep my mind active and and

um and also to connect with old friends so uh

i appreciate uh chatting with you and uh your

time and um and all your work thank you

so much it's uh it's a real pleasure thank

you all right this is the podcast of the far

right analysis network right rising i'm your

host alexander ross and this has been dr

beatrice lopez buarque um you can check out

her work as it comes out i can't wait to read

the book and and all the other great stuff

thank you very much thank you all right bye i don't know how to stop the recording there

Download Transcript