Skip to content

Transnational Opposition to Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights, ft. Lynda Gilby

Episode 67 · February 25th, 2026 · 47 mins 51 secs

About this Episode

Right-wing authoritarian and extremist movements are on the march worldwide. This podcast will host some of the globe's leading experts on the radical right to help us understand the development of these extremists. Each episode, hosts and guests bring their specialist insights to break down the critical people, places, organizations, actions, and ideas of the radical right. Produced by the Centre for Analysis of the Radical Right

Transcript

Hello, and welcome to

the Far Right Analysis Network's official

podcast, Right Rising. I'm your host,

Alexander Reed-Ross, and today we're

joined by Linda Gilby. Linda Gilby is a doctoral

candidate in global health and

development at Tampere University, where she

will then continue in the project as a

postdoctoral researcher. Her research has

focused on the global opposition to sexual

and reproductive health and rights, and their

mobilization and tactics in international

fora, such as the United Nations and European

Union institutions, with a special focus

on the far right. Hello, Linda.

Welcome to the show. Hi, thank you

Read Full Transcript Hide Full Transcript

for having me. No, it's definitely

an honor to have you, and I really

appreciate your work and the clinical

approach that you take. So, first of all, can

you talk a little bit about your project,

Transnational Flows, the impact of

transatlantic conservative networks on Finnish

and European Union environmental health and

social policies? It's a long one. Thank you.

So, yes, as you said, our project is based

at Tampere University in Finland at the Faculty

of Health Sciences, and it's led by Dr.

Valentin Pervet, and it includes two

postdoctoral researchers, Dr. Marie Cousers, Dr.

Corrado Parodi, and myself, and it's

supported by our Professor of Global Health,

Mary Koi Priscilla. So, our aim with this

project was to create an interdisciplinary

research project which would include scholars

from global health philosophy and

political sciences to examine the role

entanglements and strategies of transatlantic

conservative actors and their politics in

relation to contemporary and historical

challenges to health environmental and social

policy and when I say conservative factor.

I mean an individual organization or network

or state that seeks to resist transformative

agendas such as gender equality and

environmental regulation and prioritize

national sovereignty concerns over multilateralism

in particular. And the reason we

decided to focus on these issues and of course

while individual national contexts may differ

is because research has shown that there

have been commonalities in opposition, such

as to gender equality, sexual and reproductive

rights, public health evidence, regulations

and mandates, as well as collective global

action on climate change. And in the context

of health in particular, opposition to the

United Nations agencies, such as the World

Health Organization, have become part of a

wider focus of right -wing populist movements

and conservative think tanks, which of

course has been seen most specifically since

the COVID-19 pandemic. And so while a lot of

scholarly attention has been paid towards

movements and actors which are against

gender equality and reproductive rights, it

became clear to us that this is beyond

opposition to gender and rights, all of which has

significant consequences for public health

and global health governance. And so our

research will therefore complement the work

on right-wing populist politics and democracy

by providing insights on how policy content

debates impact public health, given

that health and social policies have become

a particular focus of right-wing populist

politics, and that these are topics that are

capable of producing depolarisation in our

societies as populist groups and politicians

have used them as leverage for mobilizing

their supporters and voters. And of course,

while populist politics have been researched

widely, we've had less focus on the

interlinkages between more specific content

areas. And furthermore, how those actors target

international decision -making forums, given

that right-wing populists have argued

that multinational forums such as the UN and

EU decision-making bodies are a threat to

national sovereignty. And also, we've seen a

merging of libertarian stances as evidenced

in Project 2025 by the Heritage Foundation,

which, of course, I'm sure many listeners

know, it is being one of the most influential

US libertarian think tanks with

transatlantic connections. And the document itself

outlines plans to remove references to

sexual and reproductive rights and climate

change and reshape gender equality as referring

only to men and women and remove also so

-called progressive social policies. And so

we've already seen the merging and meetings

between members of the Heritage Foundation and

members of conservative organizations in Europe

on these agendas, which of course we

can talk a bit about later, but essentially

what we aim to do with this project is go

beyond academic research and help decision

makers and advocates better understand the

nature and pervasiveness of the right-wing

populist agenda and their impacts on public

and global health and their linkages between

the US and Europe. Yeah, so a lot of

that is, I mean, that's extraordinarily

important. And you're talking

about also going kind of beyond their anti

-gender approach towards a larger sort of

public health approach, including environment

and social policies. But I wanted to kind

of elaborate a little bit, if you could,

about this term that you kind of pinpoint

in your work that I've never actually seen

kind of a, I don't know, um a background this

precise about before so you you write about

uh the origins of gender ideology um as

uh it was used by the catholic church as

an important part of the framework uh

within the far right uh effort to sideline

sexual and reproductive health and reproductive

of rights in favor of traditional family

values at specifically the international

conference on population and development so

this is like a um like a really specific

term that kind of has has really kind of

become the the head of this traditional family

values sort of push and it's being used

at a reoccurring conference the

International Conference on Population and

Development so can you explain what gender

ideology is you know for someone like

me who is kind of used to anti-feminism

I guess when I was growing up is what

you might call it how is gender ideology

different or yeah different from sexual

and reproductive health and reproductive rights

sure um so as you mentioned as you

mentioned it's a term developed and promoted

by the catholic church but also now they're

allied actors um to contest not only feminist

scholarship but also lgbtqi rights

comprehensive sexuality education and sexual

and reproductive health and rights and if going

forward i could use the term srhr more

broadly and it's kind of snowballed now to

target specifically a focus on trans rights

and what actors that use their opposition to

gender ideology do is they frame gender

equality as an idea rather than as an issue of

rights. By contrast, sexual reproductive

health and rights is agreed language which was

developed by consensus at the first 1994

International Conference on Population and

development. So this is a rights-based

framework which is grounded in scientific evidence

and has formed part of national level

health policies and has become embedded

in international human rights treaties and UN

documents. It's often considered as a package

deal at international negotiations and it

includes access to modern contraception,

maternal and neonatal health services,

comprehensive sexuality education, cancer

screening, treatment for SDIs, safe abortion where

legal, and of course bodily autonomy and

freedom from violence and coercion. So it's

a big package deal. The use of the term

gender ideology by opposition actors as we

see it today attempts to remove SOHR from the

realm of evidence-based policy and reframe

it as a cultural or a moral issue, rather than

as an issue of access to health services and

the right to health. So they argue that

feminism, LGBTQI rights, comprehensive sexuality

education, and sexually reproductive

health and rights threaten what they

call as the air quote natural family, which

is the heteronormative family, and even

national sovereignty. And these actors are

often referred to in the literature as anti

-gender actors, which are those who mobilize

against the legitimacy of gender equality,

which includes SRHR, and they seek to re

-establish, air quote, traditional gender

roles. So in this sense, it's not just about

opposition to SRHR, but even the word gender

itself is contested with attempts to move

it from international grammars. And so what we

see now in international negotiations is

that any resolution that contains the word

gender becomes ground for opposition and

stalling from opposition actors, leading to

delays in the adoption of agreements and the

potential watering down of language. And I

think it's important to point out here is

that a lot of these opposition actors claim

to be protecting women when these actions

and policy outcomes actually profoundly harm

women, as we're seeing in countries and states

within the US that have abortion restrictions,

and we see women with ectopic

pregnancies and septic miscarriages being denied

care, because it's not about women, right?

It's a political tool which has been used

to create fear around, and this leads to poorer

health outcomes for women, as well as,

of course, for gender diverse people right

and and that's really kind of evidenced all

over the data public health data all over

the place um so can you can you elaborate a

little more on the link between race and

reproductive rights for nationalist and populist

parties in europe because i think you

know you kind of been showing how these

things overlap. And I think that's one of

the key overlapping points that your work

kind of focuses on. Absolutely. So for

many nationalist and right-wing

populist parties, they frame motherhood

as a patriotic duty, while opposing access

to abortion services, sex education, and even

sometimes contraception. And this is

often grounded in rhetoric around the

belief that the dominant population is being

numerically or culturally replaced so in this

way we see reproductive politics becoming

a way to defend national identity and

SRHR therefore it's opposed because it

prioritizes bodily autonomy and individual rights

over demographic goals which is why

debates about abortion sexuality and family

policy are so central to contemporary

nationalist policies. So in this way,

reproductive politics becomes this mechanism

through which nationalist projects regulate

the biological and cultural reproduction

of the nation while seeking to limit the

reproductive autonomy and mobility of

migrant populations. That makes a lot of

sense. I was just talking with Valerio

Alfonso Bruno in Italy um at um poly demos

about how the um fratelli d'italia

government is sort of moderate in an outward

facing way but within italy in their domestic

policies they're like their far right

face shows specifically in this kind of

realm of biopolitics um what's that it's

an interesting nuance yeah and important

to point out yeah um that's fascinating

um is the control that they want to have

over the population and and how that

coincides with the race and

ethnicities um thank you for elucidating

that Um, so how did we

saw recently, um, the way that the

Trump administration was able to get an

international climate, you know, international

scientific body to basically

drop climate change as a

priority. And, um, I want to go back a

little bit before that and, and, uh, because

your work does really good job kind

of showing how the far right changed the

way that sexual and reproductive health or

srh and reproductive rights were being

pursued in the united nations from 2014 to

2020 so that's sort of like the the um the

prequel i guess i don't know um so so how

how did that happened how what were they

able to do like was it like a ground up thing

with kind of like you know social movement

organizations or was it like coordinated

from the top you know I don't know how

how were they able to change that and and

how did they change it yeah yeah sure um

that's a that's a really good one to talk

about and I mean I'll also add to what

you mentioned about them getting to

drop any mention of climate change is that

they've also broadened now much further

to rejecting any mention of the SDGs,

the Sustainable Development Goals. So

yes, the agenda and the opposition has

broadened dramatically. So then linking

it back to this, which is what we

found in this article. So as I mentioned

that we have this package deal

references to SRHR, which were agreed

from the 1994 ICPD. But now you're seeing,

or at least during the time of this

article, of course, and now we're seeing

opposition actors challenging the term

sexual and reproductive health and rights.

And this expanded beyond the usual

contestations to comprehensive sexuality education

and abortion, arguing that these

were against national sovereignty cultural

values and the again air quote natural or

traditional family and so this change also included

the removal of the word sexuality to an

increased emphasis on the role of families

and it also saw the removal of the reference

to access to safe abortion where legal which was

a sovereignty clause negotiated back at

the first icpd and so even now this is no

longer acceptable and I mean of course while

it's important to state that opposition to

reproductive rights is absolutely nothing

new I mean even in the initial ICPD negotiations

you know these were hard fought and the

resulting language which was formed from decades

of feminist movements for the rights and

access to services which some of us have

today and some of us are barely holding on to

an increasing number of right-wing populist

and authoritarian governments found a

powerful ally in the Trump administration and

made it hard to hold on to these gains, let

alone make any progress. And if I can give one

explicit example from that time, in 2019,

the first term of the Trump administration

threatened to veto a UN Security Council resolution

on sexual violence and conflict if they

did not remove the reference to SRHR or even

to sectional reproductive health and health

services so both of those were removed

during that time we also saw the establishment

of the Geneva Consensus Declaration in 2020

and of course they're using a title to make

it sound like a human rights document which in

itself is a tactic and so that was an explicit

attempt to expand the anti-SRHR coalition

and reframe women's health and rights

through the protection of the family as a fundamental

unit of society. And so while it adopts

language of women's health and rights,

these are only centered on women's rights as

mothers. And it does so by selectively

reinterpreting existing human rights language to

privilege heterosexual relationships and

parental authority over established sexual

reproductive health and rights frameworks

and so in that sense it functions less as

a legal instrument and more of a form

of norm contestation within global governance

which was designed to consolidate a

transnational bloc capable of challenging the

previously established consensus around SRHR

in UN negotiations. So yeah you use the

term denormalization in your work on the

global gag rule and the trump administration's

anti-abortion efforts so can you

talk a little bit about that rule it seems

pretty important to me and and how the trump

administration labels sexual and

reproductive health and reproductive rights srhr

i'll start calling it ambiguous they so they

so they call it to kind of call it ambiguous

you know as part of this denormalization

effort yeah yeah supposedly so so

ambiguous um apart from this long document in

1994 but okay so first for any listeners

who don't know what it is maybe i'll just

quickly outline what the global gaggle is

um so the mexico city policy is what it's

officially called um and was first announced

by um then u.s president ronald reagan

and has since been lifted and reinstated

by presidents along partisan lines, and it

prohibits U.S. foreign assistance to any

organization that performs or provides

counseling on abortion. And so organizations

agreeing to the policy had to pledge

not to provide abortions or even discuss

abortion, regardless of whether U.S. funds

were involved. And this is despite the

Helms Act, which has anyway prohibited

the U.S. of US foreign assistance to pay

for abortions, but this expands to whether

the US government should also restrict,

or rather gag, the activities and speech of foreign organizations using even non

-US resources. And furthermore, many

organizations affected by this policy were

also providers of modern contraception, and

so this reduced these organizations' ability

to supply modern contraceptives as well

as other reproductive health services and this

also even meant that it can impact access

to abortion services in countries where

abortion is legal which was seen in Nepal and

is therefore an example of silencing through

foreign policy where countries which were

partly reliant on U.S. global health assistance

in the provision of their health care

services were impacted. And so along with

the withdrawal of resources

that we see now, U.S. negotiators

began to characterize sexual reproductive

health and rights as, as you said, ambiguous

and even as a non -consensual term,

despite, as we discussed, the decades of use

in UN agreements. And so here I used

Dr. Rebecca Sanders' idea of norm spoiling

to explain how the Trump administration

attempts to weaken its coherence and remove

it from institutional texts and turn it

back into a matter of political disagreement.

So once that happens, every future negotiation

has to revisit the language which

was previously taken as settled, which opens

a space for rollback and therefore instead

de-normalizes it. And the global gag rule

therefore in itself is an absolute classic

example of evidence -free policy based on

ideology rather than scientific facts

because as we know from decades of evidence that

access to SRH services decreases the

amount of unwanted pregnancies and improves

maternal and infant health, while conversely

countries and states that refer to themselves

as air quote pro -life become potentially

unsafe to become pregnant and deliver a

healthy child because of the restrictions

on health services for example which deal with

pregnancy complications as well as even the

criminalization of miscarriages and we

also know from studies that have shown that

in countries which were subject to the

global lag rule they have seen an increased

number of abortions and increase in maternal

and infant infant mortality along other

health impacts such as increases in rates of

hiv infection so there is literally no public

health evidence to support the implementation

of this policy yeah i i mean i i think

you can kind of see that it's sort of like

it becomes an impassioned moral argument more

than actually a you know the the right

wing you know the the the right wing anti

-abortion sort of anti -reproductive health

argument doesn't stand on science and in fact

sort of seeks to sweep it aside with a moral

claim right so like for example this this

quote just uh sprang up uh four days ago in

the um the christian right-wing uh journal

first things um by will thibault who's at the

claremont institute he said in this in this

article first things article quote feminism

is the root and it's quiet cumulative

destruction of the family of sex differentiated

social roles and of the Western moral order

dwarfs the body count of any individual

shooting you know so feminism is murdering

people and to talk about this or that mass

shooting is you know to you know mistake the

forest for the trees because the mass shooters

I know this is where the logic takes us

the mass shooters are are desperately you

know flying against the modern world of that's

ruled by you know feminism or something like

that right so it's almost to let mass shooters

off the hook on one hand and then on the

other hand it's a Martin Bailey because

they're saying any individual shooting okay well

what about all the shootings together let's

talk about that and now you're all you're

talking about is like the terms of mass

shootings versus feminism which already is a

false equivalence the whole thing is in enormity

um but uh the argument right is that feminism

is taking lives and it's murdering people

and the primary sort of cornerstone of that

is abortions and yet when as you're saying

when anti-abortion policies kick in it

doesn't save any lives at all you know and that's

never used as you know we talk about what

sorry not we they talk about abortion being

murdered because it's so easy for them to

emote around but yet no one talks about the

murder of uh of women from being denied access

to basic care like a dnc when they're

undergoing miscarriage or something you know so

that is just not part of the discussion at

all but then also the um the incredible um

paradox in them saying in the same breath that

they're pro-life and pro-gun it's you know

it's one of those things that you want to

expand it again slowly um absolutely yeah

that's horrifying um what that what was written

thank you for sharing and um you know speaking

of public health and mortality let's

talk about the pandemic. How would you

characterize the general ways that

far-right governments and parties handled

the pandemic? Yeah, so across multiple

country contexts, of course, far-right

governments and parties tended to approach

the pandemic through this right-wing

populist anti-elite lens that reframed public

health authority as a site of political

contestation rather than of expertise. So of course

in the US you saw it most explicitly

with Dr Anthony Fauci where scientists as

well as public health agencies and international

organisations such as the World Health

Organisation were frequently constructed

as these unaccountable elites whose

recommendations threatened national sovereignty or

individual freedom, which both legitimised

non-compliance with mitigation measures, as

well as eroding trust in vaccination campaigns.

And it was this dynamic that contributed

to increasing vaccine scepticism within far

-right constituencies, where we had

opposition to mandates, which was articulated

through the language, ironically, of bodily

autonomy, you know, now bodily autonomy

is okay, as well as parental rights and

resistance to state overreach. And so the result

was not only higher levels of vaccine

hesitancy, but the consolidation of a

broader discourse around opposition to scientists

and public health experts, which then sowed

distrust of public health agencies and

multilateral governments. And what we began to

see as well is that the same transnational

networks and political actors that

had framed SRHR as an imposition by global

elites had repurposed those frames to contest

pandemic measures, reinforcing broader

political distrust towards public

health and expertise. right so we're seeing

you know this kind of discourse condensed

I guess around uh disinformation

these days you know because there is such a

a premium on rejecting science and opposing

scientists there needs to be kind of

um an overwhelming information assault

against scientific findings. So what has

the Trump administration done recently

in reference to disinformation and why

is that so dangerous? Goodness, where to

start? So the Trump administration has

dismantled much of the institutional architecture

which was designed to counter it while

framing counter disinformation efforts

as censorship, which of course was outlined

in Project 2025. And so because of that,

it therefore becomes more difficult to

govern risks, whether that is pandemics or

climate change, because the evidence base on

which policy formation depends has also been

weakened. And what we're seeing is not

a set of separate controversies, but the

consolidation of shared counter-expert

infrastructure that operates across SRHR, vaccination,

and climate science as examples. We're

seeing the same political actors, advocacy

networks, and funding streams that have

long framed SRHR as an imposition by

unaccountable global elites now deploy an almost

identical repertoire against public health

and climate expertise, such as claims of

scientific uncertainty or the language of bodily

autonomy or national sovereignty and the

elevation of parental rights and common

sense over professional knowledge and the

portrayal of multilateral institutions as

ideologically corrupted. So if I give a some

further examples of this we're seeing this

within the contemporary wellness movement which

has really become an important vector in

the circulation of health-related

disinformation in particular because it combines a

language of personal empowerment and bodily

autonomy with a deep scepticism towards

pharmaceutical industries, state regulation, and

biomedical expertise. And social media in

particular creates highly effective pathways

through which these anti-vaccine narratives

and even the promotion of unpasteurized raw

milk, for example, can travel. and so

the danger is in this way the ecosystem

normalizes the idea that individual intuition

should take precedence over scientific knowledge

which undermines the possibility of

coordinated public health responses but

if I then go back to the transnational

element in October last year There was the

launch of Make Europe Healthy Again at the

European Parliament, which was attended by

leaders of the Make America Healthy Again

and several members of MEHA's steering committee

and international advisory board, which

is a clear example of policy learning

right. And the launch was also attended by

far-right politicians, anti-vaxxers and

alternative health practitioners and

speakers who spoke about this unelected globalist

institutions such as the WHO again.

So recurring themes. Meha's founder and

president is also an anti-vaxxer

campaigner who wants tougher immigration

policy. So again, it's there, and as

opposed to the WHO. So essentially, a

lot of those on the steering committee and

international advisory board have peddled

misinformation about vaccines and

the COVID-19 pandemic. So this is a very

clear example of transatlantic

cooperation on areas which

impact health. And so the danger lies

in the erosion of the foundations that make

global health governance possible. And this

has immediate material consequences, such as

lower vaccine uptake, but it also has longer

term structural effect in that it normalizes

the idea that expertise cannot

be trusted and that

the international cooperation is a

threat to sovereignty, which makes coordinated

responses slower, weaker and more

unequal. And so, in that sense, it

transforms evidence -based global health

from a technical field into a

permanent arena of geopolitical and

ideological struggle. yeah um so coming to the end

of the questions uh um and thank you for

for your patience in in kind of um unwinding

these things uh i know it's you know it's

hard work um so can you discuss a little

bit of the role of civil society

organizations in the anti -gender campaigns more

specifically, because this is also something

I think that is increasingly important.

While you're talking about the rejection

of collaboration with sort of international

scientific efforts, there is absolutely

fairly open and opaque transnational

collaboration when it comes to mounting campaigns

against the scientists so can you talk about

like civil society organizations roles

you know in europe and in the united

states in in these anti -gender campaigns

yeah sure um so civil society organizations

are really central to contemporary anti-gender

mobilization because they provide the

organizational infrastructure the policy

expertise and the cross -border networking

capacity that allow these campaigns to

operate simultaneously at national, regional,

as well as UN levels. And there's been

detailed analysis of this by Open Democracy, as

well as the European Parliamentary Forum

for SRHR and AWID as well, which has

outlined the hundreds of millions of dollars

flowing into Europe from the US, which go

towards anti-gender mobilisation in Europe.

So rather than functioning only as grassroots

movements, many of these anti-gender

organizations draft model legislation, they train

diplomats to counter SRHR language, they

coordinate messaging, and serve as norm

entrepreneurs to roll back language on gender

and SRHR in international institutions. And

in particular, there is a growing

collaboration between U.S. conservative think tanks,

such as the Heritage Foundation and European

organizations like MCC in Hungary and

Ordo Eurus in Poland, who have made it clear

from their recently published policy briefs

which are available online that opposition

to gender inequality is embedded in a broader

project to reconfigure the institutional

architecture of the European Union itself and

particular areas of concern from one of their

latest briefs was the suggestion of the ability

of EU member states to opt out of areas

such as energy security and scientific research

cooperation, as well as a plan to dissolve

the EU to transition to a new union. So

this is where we see that it is much more

beyond opposition to gender as a concern, but

democratic institutions and multilateral

governments more broadly. Yeah, I mean, the

dissolution of the European Union is

definitely a very interesting one when

you look at the kind of different array of

far-right parties and the way that they

approach religion. You talked about Open

Democracy, their article about the World

Congress of Families has been, you know, one

of the most important that's been published

out there. and the way that they kind of

maneuver across borders to promote a different

form of transnational solidarity that they

claim, you know, represents the sovereignty of

individual nations. And the opposition to

the EU, I don't know if it's actually as

strong today as it was, you know, five

years ago, perhaps. But I guess

that's something that's kind of at play. So you talk about

how the United States Supreme Court

decisions and legislation can

influence legislation in Hungary and other

countries, like, for example, the Roe v.

Wade decision and the recent Supreme

Court, you know, re-litigation of that. And you also talk

about the controversy around the Istanbul

Convention, which is another one of these kind of

interesting moments in convention history.

I don't know if you could even use that

word. um so what's the transnational level like

in terms of the ways different far-right

parties and movements influence and support

each other like those conferences and

fake conventions and declarations that you're

talking about like on on that kind of like

institutional level what's that seem like i guess

sure so uh at the transnational level

what we see is a dense ecosystem through which

far-right parties, politicians, conservative governments,

and aligned civil society organizations

exchange strategies, and these I refer to

in my article published in Social Science and

Medicine with Professor Poivusolo, so I can

talk a little bit about it here, about

what we see at the EU level, which is that

one of the strategies of opposition is to establish

relationships with members of the european

parliament with shared views which

enable them direct access to influence eu level

language on sohr some of the anti-gender

organizations are even operating under external

financing from the us and russia to systematically

target european institutions and which

on a whole demonstrates that health-related

decisions in the eu can be subject to

lobbying from interest groups from foreign

countries with their own agendas okay of course

we saw that like just before with the maha

meha link and then there's the issue of

legitimization where hungary introduced a fetal

heartbeat requirement which was months after

the overturning of roe v wade also right

after roe v wade was overturned there was

an event organized at the european parliament

against abortion by the European Parliamentary

Group, ECR, the European Conservatives

and Reformists Group. Then we have the

creation of alternative resolutions and conventions,

which is part of this toolbox of strategies

that we presented in the article where

anti-SRHR actors attempt to delay

negotiations by submitting different texts for

debate and discussion. And there's also

the presentation of alternative resolutions

which were drafted and originated by

conservative NGOs, which demonstrates how anti

-SRHR organisations can influence the debates

in the European Parliament, and also

attempt to insert more conservative text

into policy documents. And this was also

seen in an attempt to try and draw signatures

away from the Istanbul Convention, which

is on combating violence against women.

And Poland tried to invite other countries

to leave the Istanbul Convention and

considered joining this other convention, which

was written by the conservative organization

Ordo Eurus, which was called the

Convention on the Rights of the Family. And

this mobilization against the Istanbul

Convention has circulated across Europe through

the same shared narratives about gender

ideology and national sovereignty, and it

echoes the practice seen in the creation

of the Geneva Consensus Declaration that I

mentioned earlier. So such instances led

to an open letter, which was submitted

to the President of the European Parliament,

Roberta Metzler, by MEPs in January of

2023, and it sought to withdraw the

accreditation of anti -abortion lobbyists with

transnational links. So if I give just a

few examples, because I don't remember

all of their names, but we have Alliance

Defending Freedom, Bordeaux-Eurus, and

the European Centre for Law and Justice,

among others, which cited the

potential for foreign interference in

European policymaking. So this is clear that

anti-gender actors are firmly embedded

within EU institutions and actively

try to impact discussions on SRHR,

which has impacts on access to health

services across the EU. Right. So you've

written about creating a plan of action to

defend sexual and reproductive health and

reproductive rights. SRHR. Has that come about?

Is there a plan of action formulating,

or is this sort of still germinating, I

guess? I don't know. I always try to,

it's good to end on a positive and, you

know, a call to action. There is definitely

an enormous amount of work being done by

feminist advocates, public health actors

and human rights organisations at the

national, regional, and of course,

multilateral levels. People are

doing the work, but it's not

straightforward. The money behind the

organisations that oppose gender in SRHR

is just so substantial with their networks

looking to impact global and national level

policies and so this means that the response

cannot be purely reactive or just confined

to one policy space i think one of the areas

where more strategic needing as more

strategic thinking is needed is messaging like

we were kind of talking but before um how

the um anti-gender people are so they find

it's so easy to emote around the issue of

abortion and feminism in particular they've

been extremely effective at using emotionally

charged and easily translatable narratives

where whereas the realities we're often

talking about are things like medical complications

and pregnancy and access to the health

services and health systems and these

are much more complex and harder to communicate

and so I think we definitely need closer

collaboration between scholars advocates

and policy makers and to draw on some of the

research on framing that has been done on

political communication and norm diffusion

to develop language that is both accurate

and politically effective because the urgency

is real and the consequences are already

visible and increases in maternal mortality

and morbidity and vaccine hesitancy and

vaccine preventable deaths, but also because anti

-gender mobilization is increasingly

intertwined with broader anti-democratic projects.

And so if we wait too long, we face much

bigger challenges. Yeah, absolutely. All right. Well, thank you very much for joining the program. So do you have any

articles in the works that you'd like to talk

about? any um anything coming up yeah um i i

have one which is the the the final article

of my of my doctorate um which is looking

at again a lot of what i've been talking

about here that it's beyond gender and also

that it's um looking into climate skepticism

and broader public health um opposition

in particular the the pandemic treaty which

was under negotiation at the who and so that

kind of ties in a lot of what i was saying

about the opposition to the world health

organization and how this was often targeted by

traditional anti-gender organizations as well

and a lot of their rhetoric and some of

the framing there as well as of course the

climate skepticism angle and again the

arguments of national sovereignty concerns etc

so trying to point out those interlinkages

there and calling for more scholarship on the

area because I think these issues should not

be looked at in silos and I also think there

needs to be a lot more analysis of the

public health impacts of these far right

movements that we're seeing because you know

as we know of some of the specific examples

we talked about today with, you know, being

denied access for ectopic pregnancies,

septic miscarriages, etc. These really have

concrete impacts on lives. And of course, no

one talks about those issues of being murder,

right? So yeah, I think we really need

to understand that this has really severe

impacts at the population health level, as well

as how we prepare for future pandemics

and global health emergencies so that's also

something that is very concerning as well so

that's what we have that's what i have

coming up and that is what will also form part

of our transnational flows project so um

yeah we're looking forward we look forward

to being able to share those results and

hopefully um collaborate with other people who

can help push this, you know, research

area forward and, yeah, stand in solidarity

also because these are not the most gentle

topics to write about. For sure, for sure.

All right. Well, Linda Gilby,

Transnational Flows the Impact of

Transatlantic Conservative Networks on

Finnish and EU Environmental Health

and Social Policies. thank you so much for

joining this has been right rising the

official podcast of the far right analysis

network and i'm your host alexander reed

ross i hope you join us for our next rousing

discussion and thank you very much linda

for joining thank you

Download Transcript